Opinion | Collective Punishment

-

 


By Alagie Saidy-Barrow 


Let me begin by saying I am a huge advocate for holding people accountable for their work. If people are being paid to deliver services to the public, they should be held accountable for the services they deliver, good or bad. So I am all for realistic performance evaluations. If I had my way, every single government civil or public servant would be on a contract that is tethered to their performance! 


I don’t think anyone should be in the service of the people as a public or civil servant when they somehow manage to serve themselves while the people they claim to be serving remain destitute. Serving in government should never be a vehicle for any public or civil servant to get rich when the majority of those they serve are poor! 


Imagine if my Bandam established performance evaluations for himself and all his ministers and made it all public! We will all know what each minister is required to deliver and can easily hold them to account. 


That thought brings me to the news about NAWEC staff being ducked 5% of their salaries because they didn’t meet Key Performance Indicators (KPI) targets set for 2021-2022. Reading the news about this deduction, I kept hoping that they would tell us that 5% only affects staff who occupy certain leadership positions. But from what I see in the news, it seems that is not the case. It is essentially collective punishment!! I don’t see how a lowly engineer bears the same responsibility as a director or manager such that they should be equally punished. There is no such reality as collective responsibility where there is a hierarchy and different functions. Therefore, I think the collective punishment is timidity at best. 


Wouldn’t it have been better to get to the root cause of why NAWEC has been failing Gambians for decades? Is NAWEC properly equipped to deliver on its mandate? If not, who is responsible for that? You cannot hold an institution accountable when you haven’t provided it with the necessary resources to succeed. 


Collective punishment dilutes individual responsibility. There is a reason some people at NAWEC are paid more than others. It is because they don’t all have the same or equal responsibilities. And if they don’t all have the same responsibilities and are paid based on who bears more responsibility, why must they be punished equally? It does not make sense to me and smells of a cop-out by the government.


About the Author

The author is a social and political commentator


Publisher’s Note


Views expressed herein are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the publisher. Want to be a contributing author? Please email opmail220@gmail.com



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular OP posts

‘Industrial Scale’ Foreign Disinformation Campaigns Fuel Anger, Confusion

-
Image
Dai Russian President Vladimir Putin, left, and Chinese President Xi Jinping wave during the welcoming ceremony of an economic summit. Disinformation campaigns seeking to manipulate African information systems have increased nearly fourfold since 2022. That is according to the Africa Center for Strategic Studies (ACSS), which linked disinformation campaigns to increased violence, support for coups, expanded anti-Western rhetoric and the spread of confusion about health care. These campaigns also work to erode confidence in traditional media sources. Nearly 60% of disinformation campaigns in Africa are linked to countries outside the continent. The efforts, aided by emerging technology, are mostly driven by Russia, although China, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates also push false narratives as they seek to spread their influence. Such contrived narratives are flourishing as Africa now has more than 400 million active social media users and 600 million internet users. ...
Read more

GPU Validates, Train Journalists on Assault & Battery Guide

-
Image
  The Gambia Press Union (GPU) today began a two-day validation of a draft Assault and Battery Guide for Journalists as well as train 25 participants on how to utlise the guide as part of efforts to address impunity for violent attacks on journalists and media workers. This event forms part of activities under the EU-funded Consolidation of Democratic Dispensation in The Gambia (CODE) implemented by International IDEA, and meant to support participatory, inclusive, and human rights-based democratic transition in The Gambia. The validation and capacity building are aimed at providing journalists and media workers with the legal knowledge and understanding of process and procedures for seeking redress on assault cases and similar violations of press freedom. Since 2017, the GPU has documented numerous incidents of journalists facing assault and intimidation, primarily from political party supporters and security forces. None of these cases, some of which are reported to the police, h...
Read more

Deputy Speaker Welcomes EU Delegation to Discuss Electoral Reforms

-
Image
    The Honourable Deputy Speaker, Seedy SK Njie, welcomed a high-ranking European Union (EU) delegation led by Ambassador-Designate Immaculada Roca I Cortes. The high-level meeting focused on reviewing the progress made on the implementation of the recommendations made by the EU after The Gambia's 2021 elections, particularly as the country looks forward to its next electoral cycle beginning in 2026.  The EU post-electoral report made 20 recommendations, of which 15 targeted legal reforms to enhance electoral fairness and transparency. The meeting discussed EU concerns regarding transparency measures and access to information within the National Assembly by the general public. In response, Deputy Speaker Njie highlighted several initiatives, including a dedicated communications unit, committee-led townhall meetings and oversight activities, live-streamed sessions, and open media access to parliamentary proceedings. The continuity of consultations with civil society organ...
Read more